Far from the original tightening of measures announced, the regulatory burden has eased significantly in Europe: the Omnibus I directive has cut the CSRD's scope by roughly 80%, reducing coverage from 50,000 companies to around 10,000, including 1,200 in France. In Asia, no unified regulatory framework yet exists. ESG discourse, for its part, has receded worldwide.
Yet, this lighter regulatory burden has produced no retreat in progress in the field. 7 in 10 responding companies have already measured their carbon footprint, and for close to two-thirds of them, the exercise has become annual. For the study's authors, carbon measurement has detached itself from its regulatory trigger, and become a management standard, driven more by internal conviction than obligation.
Brian Hill, CNRS Research Professor in Economics and Decision Sciences at HEC Paris, commented: “The Radar shows that carbon reporting is no longer driven by regulation alone: customers and competitors are now the most powerful forces for transparency, with a significant role remaining for voluntary leadership, especially in Europe. This can create a market dynamic of its own – companies disclose because stakeholders value the information and because, once others are transparent, staying silent becomes harder. This is precisely the kind of bottom-up dynamic highlighted and studied in our ongoing work at the HEC Paris Sustainability and Organizations Center on creating the conditions for smarter sustainability disclosure.”



